Group Chat Recap
09•19•24

'Holy Bleeping Bleep'

What it feels like to build a functioning CRM in 3 hours, and 4 other takeaways about AI and team management.

Editor’s Note: This Group Chat was a prolific blend of personalities and perspectives spanning a variety of unrelated industries. We provoked this group with practical questions about AI and management. Their respective answers fed into a good discourse. Here’s a public-facing recap)

0:00 / 0:00

People are always asking what happens in our events. We can’t tell you. That’s part of our deal; we have closed-door sessions with real discourse. Our members get to share raw thoughts, compare notes, and develop new connections. And you get this sanitized recap.

This group had 4 members:

  • 2 Founders (1 AI startup and 1 large public company & venture development firm)
  • 1 Chief Digital Officer in prestigious cultural commerce
  • 1 Chief Operating Officer of an agency

They generated 5 takeaways.

Matt Chmiel

Matt Chmiel

Discover more discourse directly in your inbox.

Sign up for the ON_Discourse Newsletter.

SUBSCRIBE

1. Middle Management is Ready for an AI Take Over

In private they don’t mince words: “We want to replace the manager, just like Uber replaced the dispatcher. AI can do a better job at managing people than humans. Managers are the most dysfunctional part of an organization, and people leave jobs because of bad managers, not bad companies.” The role of the manager as we know it is obsolete.

Another participant, tired of slow corporate change, took drastic measures within their company, reshuffling the hierarchy to move faster: “We took our chief creative officer, made them Chief AI Officer, and launched initiatives to trim the fat.” The focus here was cutting out inefficiency and embracing AI as a force for operational speed and innovation.

Managers are the most dysfunctional part of an organization, and people leave jobs because of bad managers, not bad companies.

2. AI Prototyping: Faster Than Bureaucracy Can Keep Up

With greater efficiency comes an unexpected issue. As one exec put it: “We spun up an AI-driven CRM prototype in just three hours, and the reaction was ‘holy fucking shit.’” But the challenge surfaced when this quick success bumped into a familiar corporate problem: maintenance. As this leader explained, “Now, I don’t know what to do. If everyone starts using it, it becomes a product, and then I need to support it.”

The prototype worked so well but it was just a proof of concept. Implementing this thing is where it gets sticky again.

This dilemma—building too fast to scale—captures the double-edged sword of today’s AI landscape. It’s faster to build something tangible than to even discuss building it, but as they pointed out, “The challenge comes when you have to support and scale what was meant to be a prototype.”

3. Mediocrity Won’t Survive

Another issue: people. They put it bluntly: mediocrity will not survive in this new AI-driven world. “Being mediocre is just going to be very difficult.” The pace of AI innovation is outstripping human adaptability. The faster the models retrain, the faster the gaps between skill levels grow. In this environment, anyone slow to adapt will be left behind.

The Chief AI Officer that was mentioned earlier is in charge of hiring new resources. All of them have to demonstrate real opinions, experience, and output from various AI platforms if they want to get hired.

4. Donkeycorn Ventures

Forget unicorns. While some chase billion-dollar valuations, a new concept emerged during the discussion—the “donkey-corn.” This represents small, high-performing companies with $2 million in revenue, built by tiny teams grinding hard in niche markets. The future belongs to companies focused on efficiency and scalability without bloating. Someone referred to the Sam Altman question: “Who’s going to be the first billion-dollar brand owned by one person?” That question does not imply a single business. In this executive's mind, it is a network of donkeycorns.

5. AI-First Companies

One consistent theme throughout the chat was the consensus that any new company starting today is an AI-first company. “You have two types of people: those who embrace change and those who fight it. Only one of them wins.” Whether it’s AI managing teams or personalizing brand experiences, the clear takeaway was this: the future is not waiting for anyone. The business leaders in this chat agreed—AI isn’t just a tool; it’s a revolution in how work will be done.

We run a Group Chat every week. If you want to participate, inquire about membership here. If you want to keep up with the perspectives that we hear, you can subscribe to our weekly newsletter.

Kiss

Marry

& Kill

Taking stock of the internet before it totally changes

The Internet

From the editor: The ON_Discourse team dispatched to Austin for the 2024 SXSW with a dorm-room style ice-breaker question that generated much more introspection than we expected. More than that, this playful question dominated many of our events; one person’s answer inevitably sparked an impassioned response from someone else. If the internet as we know it is poised for a major change, should we be surprised by this reaction?

We are on the brink of a new internet. It looms over the horizon like a storm that we know will realign many of the conventions that define the web today. The changes to come are fundamentally unpredictable; we simply know they will be profound. As this storm approaches, many of our members are taking stock of the web itself; what they love, hate, and hope about it.

We tapped into this sentiment at SXSW this year with one of the most juvenile ice-breaker questions we’ve asked so far in our journey. What would you kiss, marry, and kill about the internet of the past, present, and future. The question drew an immediate reaction – maybe it was the tequila – that went surprisingly deep. We were just trying to have fun so we could get some raw perspective for this moment.

The following perspectives were overheard at SXSW:

Matt Chmiel
Head of Discourse

EXPLORE ISSUE #006

What I would

Kiss

The features, apps, and conventions that briefly infatuate us. They seem so wonderful at first, but something about them fails to deliver.

Notifications

God they were amazing at first, but now it’s insane. They are interrupting everything in our lives and totally not worth it. — AI entrepreneur

DAOs

Idealistically what it represents is something that something that is built around a set of core values, shared values. People join and are a part of something because they all they all have something in common.

Search

Being able to search, I think it’s so powerful, but the format of this experience is not right. The way it works now is you enter this search term and get these 12 links which forces you to refine that search with 12 more links, right? I would want to get rid of that and have it be a more natural, predictive way of talking and searching. — Brand Executive

Flash

It was so fun and sexy and I miss it. — CEO

Algorithms

Algorithmic sharing of content. We sorted it and we’ve reached its logical extreme and it was a good run. We’re great at it; we dominated; we won. By winning, we lost. We lost because, literally, what will get shared is what will what will suck you in which is low quality content whenever you need it. — CEO

Outbrain

It sucked and was stupid, but it could have been amazing. — Brand Executive

Discover more discourse directly in your inbox.

Sign up for the ON_Discourse Newsletter.

SUBSCRIBE

What I would

Marry

The long-term opportunities and features that showcase the best of what the internet can offer end-users, brands, and platforms. This is way bigger than infatuation; this is love.

Online Gaming

I think gaming will combine movies and storytelling – big narration – that is going to be really interesting. Then you can actually kind of be a part of it. And with that comes all that personalization that creates your flavor of that. It’s going to be huge. — AI entrepreneur

LinkedIn

As a productivity tool that supports what we do at a professional level, I think it’s phenomenal. And a social network that seems to have maintained a level of positivity that doesn’t exist elsewhere. — Famous podcaster

Spatial Computing

I believe it’s in it for the long term. It’s not just flashy and sexy right now, though it is. But it will be transformative and here for a long time and continue to evolve and get better like any good marriage. — CEO

Blockchain

We are selling it wrong; this is not meant to be a front-end benefit. No one needs to know what’s even there. But I think it will underpin the next internet. I’m thinking about the fediverse side stuff and the decentralization of our social networks for example, or being able to move your identity wherever you want. I get so excited by tokens and authenticity. — Brand executive

Blockchain (again)

It is the most boring thing I could possibly say. But I actually do believe that blockchain as an identity-based solution will change the way we use the internet forever. — CMO

Home Pages

They are still one of the most overlooked pieces of the internet. Don’t sleep on the value of a really good home page, no matter what everyone tells you about side door entries. — Brand Executvie

What I would

Kill

Do we need to explain this one any further?

iMessage

Two reasons: one, monopolistic dominance over any other potential competing products; and two, because the user experience just fucking sucks, and a company with $400 billion in cash on hand that cannot in any way innovate around making something that they have a non monopoly over better is very risky. This is one of the most frustrating things about Apple to me and I love that company. — Founder

SmartPhones

iPhone neck and other issues with this stupid screen we keep in front of our faces like that. — Founder

SmartPhones (again)

Its days are numbered so I’m just getting it over with. — CEO

Social Media

I would kill it in the way that it represents a fake life. Yep. Right. So this whole story of ‘I’m living my best life and everyone is living a better life than me.’ Right? I would kill that party. — Brand executive

Fortnight

They are creating unchecked environments for minors and kids to engage in behaviors that are resulting in mental health and socially unhealthy behaviors and actions. — CMO 

Ad-Funded Content

I think that the main problem with the internet today is that it’s fully advertising-funded, right? With only a few exceptions. And the problem with advertising-funded means that we don’t give a fuck about the quality of the content. — CEO